J Street’s 'Big Tent’ is open only to one side - the anti-Israel and BDS-supporting hard left of its own position; pro-Israel centrists are censored.
By Alan M. Dershowitz
J
Street, the American organization that calls itself pro-Israel and pro
peace but that always seems to be taking positions that are anti-Israel
and pro-Palestinian, is asking America’s Jewish leadership to have a big
tent and to open its doors to J Street. While I generally support that
position, it is imperative that J Street’s hypocrisy be exposed. J
Street insists that all major pro-Israel organizations be open to
speakers who favor opposing views—such as supporters of the BDS
movements, supporters of the single secular binational state approach,
and those who oppose Palestinian recognition of Israel as the
nation-state of the Jewish people.In the abstract, this open tent policy seems commendable. We should be committed to the open marketplace of ideas in which views prevail on their merits not on the basis of exclusion.
Now let’s see how J Street itself fares with regard to an open tent policy. It has categorically refused to allow speakers like me, who oppose J Street’s policies on Iran and other security matters, to speak to its members at its conventions. I have repeatedly and persistently sought an opportunity to present my perspective—which is shared by many American supporters of Israel—at the J Street convention, or at other events officially sponsored by J Street. When J Street invites BDS supporters and those oppose Israel’s right to exist as the nation-state of the Jewish people to speak at its events, it claims that it does not necessarily support these positions, but it believes in encouraging its members to hear views that are different from its official positions. That is total nonsense. J Street only wants people to hear views to the anti-Israel hard left of its position. It categorically refuses to allow its members to hear views that are more centrist and more pro-Israel, such as my own.
Continue reading.
During
a visit yesterday to Jerusalem's Hebrew University, David Willetts said
that such perceptions were to blame for a marked decline in the number
of Israelis choosing to study in the UK.
The
Loyola United Student Government Association voted March 18 to call on
the university to remove its holdings from eight companies that provide
equipment to Israel for use in the West Bank. The vote on a measure
proposed by the Loyola chapter of Students for Justice in Palestine
passed 26-0 with two abstentions.
It often happens in sensitive negotiations between longtime adversaries. At a certain point they start talking in code.
JERUSALEM—Israel’s
political leadership has ordered the Israel Defense Forces to continue
preparations for a military strike against Iran’s nuclear facilities
despite the interim agreement arrived at last November between Teheran
and Western nations, Ha’aretz reported today.
Three
decades ago, Judy Feld Carr started smuggling members of Syria’s
minority Jewish community out of the country. She talks to The Daily
Beast about her secret work saving people from slaughter under Assad.
President
Shimon Peres said on Monday that Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas is
a "true partner for peace." Peres made the remarks upon an expected
summit later Monday in Washington between Abbas and US President Barack
Obama.
According
to tradition, around 1,900 years before the Spanish Inquisition, a baby
girl named Hadassah was born in the Persian Empire. She was orphaned at
a very young age and her cousin Mordechai assumed custody of her. Under
his tutelage, she internalized the spark of her Jewish identity.
It’s
been three years since the civil war broke out in Syria, and there is
no end in sight. More than 120,000 people have been killed so far.
Two-and-a-half million Syrians are refugees. The damage to the country’s
infrastructure is estimated at $3 billion.
The
quixotic, well-meaning search for a two-state solution to the
Arab-Israeli conflict is futile, and it always has been. That statement
is not offered as an ideological trumpet call for annexing the West Bank
or an emotional cri de coeur. Rather, it is meant to provide a
realistic perspective, one needed to see future prospects with clear
eyes.
I’m
joined by family and friends, including one friend who, in her uniform
with a gun strapped over her shoulder, and a tallit wrapped around her,
danced to the psalms of Hallel.
“We
all have so much to gain from peace. Peace would be good for us. Peace
would be good for the Palestinians,” Netanyahu told the annual American
Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC) gathering in Washington. “But
peace would also open up the possibility of establishing formal ties
between Israel and leading countries in the Arab world.”
Only
one thing went wrong during Israel’s naval raid in the Red Sea
Wednesday morning – the timing. It’s easy to imagine that it was
slightly disappointing, at least to Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu.
Had it taken place during his address to the AIPAC conference in
Washington on Tuesday, he really could have gone to town. It was all
there in a nutshell, everything Netanyahu has been warning us about for
years: Iran, Syria, long-range missiles, the threat in the Gaza Strip.
The axis of evil is alive and well, and against all the odds our brave
warriors go forth and neutralize these threats far from Israel’s
borders.
JNS.org
– Israeli soldiers operating in Hebron on Tuesday night arrested Ayyub
al-Kawasma, a senior Hamas operative who has been on Israel’s wanted
list since 1998, Israel Hayom reported. The joint operation of the
Israel Defense Forces and Shin Bet security agency was carried out by
the IDF’s elite Duvdevan unit.
He
opened with a paean to Israeli and American exceptionalism, calling
both democracies “lights unto the nations,” and reassuring the assembled
delegates that “as Israel faces significant challenges to her future,
it is America who will stand firmly by her side.” Then came the turn to
Iran, the greatest source of tension between AIPAC and the current
administration. “We will not permit Iran to obtain a nuclear
weapon–period,” Kerry avowed, to a standing ovation. Only after catering
to the crowd’s comfort zone did Kerry defend diplomacy, with one-liners
carefully crafted to dispel any accusations of naivete. “This is not a
process about trusting Tehran, it is about testing Tehran,” he said.
“And you can be sure that if Iran fails this test, America will not fail
Israel.”
(JTA) — A documentary about the world’s oldest Holocaust survivor won an Oscar one week after she died.